Raw diets has become quite popular among pet owners who want to give their pets a more “natural” way to feed. Social media especially tends to promote raw meat diets as a way to improve coat quality, digestion, and overall health.

But is a raw diet actually safer for dogs and cats?

At Gaia Vets, we often get questions from pet owners about raw feeding. While feeding raw meat may seem closer to what animals eat in the wild, veterinary research shows that raw diets can carry several risks for both pets and their families.

Let’s take you through some considerations so you can make more informed choices about raw diets!

What’s a Raw Diet for Dogs and Cats?

A raw diet typically consists of uncooked animal ingredients such as:

• Raw meat
• Organs
• Bones
• Eggs
• Fruits or vegetables

Raw diets are often marketed under several names, including:

• BARF diet (Biologically Appropriate Raw Food or Bones and Raw Food)
• Raw meat based diets (RMBDs)
• Frozen raw pet food
• Freeze-dried raw pet food 

Some owners prepare these meals at home, while others buy commercially packaged raw diets.

Although these diets are commonly advertised as healthier or more natural, current veterinary evidence raises concerns about food safety and nutritional balance.

Risks of Feeding a Raw Diet to Dogs & Cats

1. Risk of Harmful Bacteria in Raw Pet Food

Raw meat frequently contains bacteria that are normally eliminated during cooking.

Common bacteria found in raw pet food include:

• Salmonella
• Escherichia coli (E. coli)
• Listeria
• Campylobacter

Because raw diets skip the cooking process, these bacteria may remain in the food and infect pets or humans who handle them. 

Studies have shown that raw pet food products may contain pathogens capable of causing illness, while properly cooked commercial pet foods generally do not. 

Pets that consume contaminated raw food may also shed bacteria in their stool even if they do not appear sick. This increases the risk of bacteria spreading around the home via food bowls, litter boxes, pet saliva etc.

If you’ve got children, elderly family members, pregnant individuals, or immunocompromised people, they all face a higher risk of infection.
 

2. Risk of Antibiotic Resistant Bacteria

Another growing concern is antimicrobial resistance.
Some raw pet foods have been found to contain bacteria carrying antibiotic-resistant genes. These bacteria may spread between pets and humans, and can potentially contribute to infections that are harder to treat.

This is one of the key reasons veterinary and public health organisations caution against raw feeding.

3. Risk of Parasites & Zoonotic Diseases

Raw meat may also contain parasites and infectious organisms that can affect both animals and humans. Examples include:

• Toxoplasma
• Tapeworms
• Brucella bacteria
   

These pathogens can spread through contaminated food or surfaces in the home.
 

4. The Issue of Nutritional Imbalances

Dogs and cats require carefully balanced levels of nutrients, including:

• Calcium and phosphorus
• Essential fatty acids
• Vitamins and trace minerals
• Taurine and L-carnitine
   

Many home prepared raw diets are unable to meet these requirements compared to formulated kibbles/wet food made by reputable manufacturers. 

Long term nutritional imbalances may lead to health problems such as:

• Bone abnormalities in growing animals
• Organ damage
• Weak immunity
• Heart disease in cats due to taurine deficiency

Young pets such as puppies and kittens are especially vulnerable to improper nutrition during growth and pet owners should avoid raw diets for this reason.

Other FAQs on Raw Diets

Is Freeze Dried Raw Pet Food Safer?

Freeze-dried raw diets are often marketed as a safer alternative to frozen raw food because of its preparation method.

Freeze drying removes moisture from food to extend shelf life, but it does not reliably eliminate harmful bacteria. This means pathogens present in raw meat may still survive the freeze drying process.

Studies analysing commercial raw pet foods have identified disease causing microbes and antibiotic resistant bacteria in frozen, refrigerated, and freeze-dried raw diets.

Some manufacturers use additional safety steps such as high pressure processing to reduce bacterial contamination. While this can lower bacterial levels, it still may not completely eliminate all pathogens.

For this reason, freeze-dried raw diets should still be handled with the same caution as other raw foods.

What Do Vets Recommend Instead?

Most vets (including our team at Gaia Vets) recommend feeding a complete and balanced commercial diet. 

Look for diets that meet recognised nutritional standards such as:

• AAFCO feeding trials or nutrient profiles
• WSAVA nutritional guidelines
• Veterinary formulated diets

These diets are carefully designed to provide:

•  Balanced protein, fats, and carbohydrates
• Correct mineral ratios
• Essential vitamins and amino acids
• Strict manufacturing quality control

Both dry kibbles and wet food can work well depending on your pet’s needs. Many pet owners choose to feed a combination of wet and dry food to increase hydration and dietary variety.

Is Raw Diet Alright For Puppies or Kittens?

For young pets, we generally recommend:

• Puppy or kitten specific diets designed for growth
• Breed-appropriate formulations, especially for large breed puppies
• Monitoring body condition to prevent overfeeding

Large breed puppies especially will need controlled calcium and energy levels to support proper bone development. It is best to avoid feeding unbalanced homemade diets during growth stages unless it is formulated by a veterinary nutritionist.
 

Should You Rotate Foods to Prevent Allergies?

Many pet owners believe rotating foods can prevent allergies.
In reality, true food allergies in pets are relatively uncommon. Most allergies in dogs and cats are caused by environmental factors rather than diet.

However, good feeding practices include:

•  Introducing new proteins gradually
• Avoiding extreme fad diets (including raw or vegan diets)
• Maintaining a nutritionally balanced diet

If a pet develops chronic itching, ear infections, or digestive issues, your vet may recommend a structured elimination diet to identify food allergies.

Is A Homecooked Diet Better?

Some pets may require home cooked diets due to medical conditions.
In these cases, the diet should always be formulated with the guidance of your vet to ensure proper nutrient balance.

Simply feeding meat, vegetables, and supplements is rarely sufficient to meet all of a pet’s nutritional needs.

The Conclusion on Raw Diets

Raw diets, including freeze-dried raw food, are often promoted as natural alternatives to commercial pet food. However, research shows they may carry several risks, including:

1. Bacterial contamination
2. Antibiotic resistant pathogens
3. Parasites and zoonotic disease
4. Nutritional imbalances

For most pets, a complete and balanced commercial diet remains the safest and most reliable choice.

If you are not sure what diet is best for your dog or cat, come speak to our vets! We can help ensure your pets receive the nutrition they need for every stage of life.